Friday, October 9, 2009

Epidemiological Thinking

"One is not perfect,
so do epidemiological studies"
-intuition.

When we read a paper published into the Medical Journal and see the result, we do not straight away accept the result as the truth (the association between two things, e.g exercise and heart attack or smoking and breast cancer).

We must first look at other possible or alternative explanations which can be:
1.Bias
2.Confounding
3.Chance.

Could the result be biased?

Could the result be Confounded by something else?

Could the result occur due to chance (by luck) ?

If all the answers lead to a 'no' - which is unlikely, then we can accept the association as the truth.

However, since it is always unlikely for us to get all the answers to be 'no' we need to be cautious of that association, who knows that the association is the truth. In addition, since we are able to detect what is wrong with that study ( contains bias,confounding or chance or all of them together) we can make a comment about it.

Now, I am thinking if we can apply this way of seeing things - the epidemiologist's alternatives - into other situations such as when we see a person's behavior or decision.

For instance, someone made a decision to buy a car, or perhaps said something that is really disheartening.

Before we can say something or point our finger and accept the truth - the true association ( fight back ). We need to look at three things:

1.Could what the person said be biased?

2.Could what the person said be confounded by something else?

3.Could what the person said be due to luck (or chance) - could it be just our lucky day to receive such a sentence? = today's his or her bad / good day or good mood / bad mood.

If all the answers to the above questions is a 'no' (which is unlikely) then you could point your finger at that person.

However, since it is unlikely for all the answers to be 'no', we need to always be cautious with that person.Not to forget if you can detect either one of the three factors above, we can make a comment about it which can be either a comment at heart, in the 'books' ( a personal notebook) or, at our own risk to the person him or herself

this post is supposed to be funny.
cheers.

No comments:

Post a Comment